Emily Tan
Jul 24, 2012

Siri's inaccuracy may keep it a novelty

GLOBAL - Nearly a year after its launch, Apple's Siri is still far from the accurate and helpful personal assistant that Apple has been advertising, according to a study by investment bank and asset management firm Piper Jaffray.

New study finds Siri isn't quite as accurate as her advertising implies
New study finds Siri isn't quite as accurate as her advertising implies

The report, cited in Fortune, found that Siri only understood 83 per cent of queries in noisy conditions and 89 per cent in a quiet room. Perhaps worse, Siri only answered accurately 62 per cent of the time in a street and 68 per cent in a quiet room. 

 

By contrast Google understood 100 per cent of the questions and replied accurately 86 per cent of the time. Overall, Siri received an accuracy grade of D and Google a B+. 

The study was conducted by a research analyst at Piper Jaffray, Gene Munster, who asked an iPhone 1,600 questions, 800 on the streets of Minneapolis and 800 in a quiet room. He also compared Siri's performance against Google search (Fortune assumed that the search was keyed in and not voice-activated). Examples suggested that even apart from the voice-recognition challenge, Siri performs worse than Google at interpreting the intent of the user's question when wording is ambiguous. 

In conclusion, Munster wrote that Siri simply didn't stack up against Google and was therefore not ready to be a viable mobile search alternative.

By Munster's estimation, Siri lags about two years behind Google but expects Siri to "improve meaningfully" with the release of iOS 6. 

For advertisers, this could mean a delay in tapping into the potential of voice-activated search, whether via search engine marketing or through voice-activated coupons

Source:
Campaign Asia

Follow us

Top news, insights and analysis every weekday

Sign up for Campaign Bulletins

Related Articles

Just Published

2 hours ago

Apple’s latest campaign celebrates innovation in ...

Known as ‘circles', the student-led teams push boundaries in fields including hybrid rocket engineering, stop-motion animation, game development and sports analytics.

3 hours ago

Ahead of Trump's second-term, Meta to scrap fact ...

Traditional fact-checking will make way for X-inspired "community notes." This drastic overhaul signals a major shift in content moderation as the tech giant appears to appease the incoming Trump administration.

6 hours ago

40 Under 40 2024: Ryan Cheung, PressLogic

Cheung’s risk-taking and entrepreneurial spirit seeps into all facets of the company he founded—across growth, operations, and innovation.

7 hours ago

Woolley Marketing: Why change is not always a ...

From Netflix to Nvidia, true disruption is rare. Darren Woolley shares his nuanced perspective on the difference between evolution and revolution in business.